Remembering Allan McDonald: He Refused To Approve Challenger Launch, Exposed Cover-Up

Mar 7, 2021
Originally published on March 8, 2021 4:57 pm

On Jan. 27, 1986, Allan McDonald stood on the cusp of history.

McDonald directed the booster rocket project at NASA contractor Morton Thiokol. He was responsible for the two massive rockets, filled with explosive fuel, that lifted space shuttles skyward. He was at the Kennedy Space Center in Florida for the launch of the Challenger "to approve or disapprove a launch if something came up," he told me in 2016, 30 years after Challenger exploded.

His job was to sign and submit an official form. Sign the form, he believed, and he'd risk the lives of the seven astronauts set to board the spacecraft the next morning. Refuse to sign, and he'd risk his job, his career and the good life he'd built for his wife and four children.

"And I made the smartest decision I ever made in my lifetime," McDonald told me. "I refused to sign it. I just thought we were taking risks we shouldn't be taking."

McDonald persistently cited three reasons for a delay: freezing overnight temperatures that could compromise the booster rocket joints; ice forming on the launchpad and spacecraft that could damage the orbiter heat tiles at launch; and a forecast of rough seas at the booster rocket recovery site.

He also told NASA officials, "If anything happens to this launch, I wouldn't want to be the person that has to stand in front of a board of inquiry to explain why we launched."

Now, 35 years after the Challenger disaster, McDonald's family reports that he died Saturday in Ogden, Utah, after suffering a fall and brain damage. He was 83 years old.

"There are two ways in which [McDonald's] actions were heroic," recalls Mark Maier, who directs a leadership program at Chapman University and produced a documentary about the Challenger launch decision.

"One was on the night before the launch, refusing to sign off on the launch authorization and continuing to argue against it," Maier says. "And then afterwards in the aftermath, exposing the cover-up that NASA was engaged in."

Twelve days after Challenger exploded, McDonald stood up in a closed hearing of a presidential commission investigating the tragedy. He was "in the cheap seats in the back" when he raised his hand and spoke. He had just heard a NASA official completely gloss over a fundamental fact.

McDonald and his team of Thiokol engineers had strenuously opposed the launch, arguing that freezing overnight temperatures, as low as 18 degrees F, meant that the O-rings at the booster rocket joints would likely stiffen and fail to contain the explosive fuel burning inside the rockets. They presented data showing that O-rings had lost elasticity at a much warmer temperature, 53 degrees F, during an earlier launch.

The NASA official simply said that Thiokol had some concerns but approved the launch. He neglected to say that the approval came only after Thiokol executives, under intense pressure from NASA officials, overruled the engineers.

"I was sitting there thinking that's about as deceiving as anything I ever heard," McDonald recalled. "So ... I said I think this presidential commission should know that Morton Thiokol was so concerned, we recommended not launching below 53 degrees Fahrenheit. And we put that in writing and sent that to NASA."

Former Secretary of State William Rogers chaired the commission and stared into the auditorium, squinting in the direction of the voice.

"I'll never forget Chairman Rogers said, 'Would you please come down here on the floor and repeat what I think I heard?' " McDonald said.

The focus of the commission's investigation shifted to the booster rocket O-rings, the efforts of McDonald and his colleagues to stop the launch and the failure of NASA officials to listen.

Morton Thiokol executives were not happy that McDonald spoke up, and they demoted him.

That alarmed members of the presidential commission and members of Congress. Rep. Edward Markey, a Massachusetts Democrat, introduced a joint resolution in the House that threatened to forbid Thiokol from getting future NASA contracts given the company's punishment of McDonald and any other Thiokol engineers who spoke freely.

The company relented, and McDonald was promoted to vice president and put in charge of the effort to redesign the booster rocket joints that failed during the Challenger launch.

In 1988, the redesigned joints worked successfully as shuttle flights resumed.

McDonald continued to work at Thiokol until 2001 and retired after 42 years. He later co-authored one of the most definitive accounts of the Challenger disaster — Truth, Lies, and O-Rings: Inside the Space Shuttle Challenger Disaster.

In 2018, Allan McDonald reviewed the Challenger launch decision during a series of seminars about leadership and ethical decision-making to managers at U.S. Space Command.
Mark Maier

In retirement, McDonald became a fierce advocate of ethical decision-making and spoke to hundreds of engineering students, engineers and managers. He and Chapman University's Maier held leadership and ethics seminars for corporations and government agencies, including U.S. Space Command.

Maier says that one of McDonald's key moments in his talks helps explain his ability to reconcile his brush with history.

"What we should remember about Al McDonald [is] he would often stress his laws of the seven R's," Maier says. "It was always, always do the right thing for the right reason at the right time with the right people. [And] you will have no regrets for the rest of your life."

"It's really that simple if you just keep it focused that way," McDonald told me in 2016.

He also framed regret another way, paraphrasing a favorite quote from the late journalist Sydney J. Harris.

"Regret for things we did is tempered by time," McDonald said, his expression firm. "But regret for things we did not do is inconsolable." McDonald then paused and added, "That's absolutely true."

He seemed inconsolable immediately after the Challenger explosion in tearful calls home. He recalls the painful conversations in his book. "I feel like it's my fault," he told his daughter Lisa, a nursing student in Boston at the time. "Don't blame yourself, Dad," she said, also crying.

Maier believes McDonald lived out his life with neither blame nor regret. "He died with serenity and equanimity," he says. "I will miss him dearly."

Allan McDonald leaves behind his wife, Linda, and four children — and a legacy of doing the right things at the right times with the right people.

Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

SCOTT DETROW, HOST:

We are remembering someone who played a major role in the fatal launch of the space shuttle Challenger. Allan McDonald died Saturday in Ogden, Utah, at age 83. He was one of the people who tried to stop the launch and later exposed an apparent cover-up. Howard Berkes has this remembrance.

HOWARD BERKES, BYLINE: On January 27, 1986, Allan McDonald stood at the cusp of history. Sign the form, he believed, and he'd risk the lives of seven astronauts set to board the space shuttle Challenger. Refuse to sign, and he'd risk his job, his career and the good life he built for his wife and four children.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

ALLAN MCDONALD: That was a reason I was at the Cape, as it required that a senior official be at the Cape to approve or disapprove a launch if something came up. And I made the smartest decision I ever made in my lifetime. I refused to sign it. I just thought, we're taking risks we shouldn't be taking.

BERKES: McDonald worked for NASA contractor Morton-Thiokol and was responsible for the two massive rockets filled with explosive fuel which lifted shuttles toward space. Hours before his decisive moment, the forecast called for 18 degrees, the coldest launch ever. His engineers knew that rubber O-rings, seals that contain burning fuel, stiffened in cold weather and didn't seal, which is precisely what happened. Seven lives were lost.

MARK MAIER: There are two ways in which Al's actions were heroic.

BERKES: Mark Maier directs a leadership program at Chapman University and has studied the Challenger launch decision.

MAIER: One was on the night before the launch, refusing to sign off on the launch authorization and continuing to argue against it. And then afterwards, in the aftermath, exposing the cover-up that NASA was engaged in.

BERKES: A presidential commission investigated the Challenger disaster. And during a closed hearing, McDonald was shocked when a NASA official glossed over a fundamental fact. The Thiokol engineers vigorously opposed the launch and formally recommended a delay, but they were overruled under pressure from NASA by Thiokol executives who signed the launch authorization McDonald refused to sign.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

MCDONALD: I was sitting there thinking, that's about as deceiving as anything I ever heard. So I raised my hand. I said, I think this presidential commission should know that Morton-Thiokol was so concerned, we recommended not launching below 53 degrees Fahrenheit. And we put that in writing and sent that to NASA. I'll never forget Chairman Rogers said, would you please come down here on the floor and repeat what I think I heard?

BERKES: The investigation shifted to the O-rings, to the Thiokol engineers and to NASA's refusal to listen. McDonald was demoted for speaking up until members of the commission and Congress intervened. They vowed Thiokol would never get another federal contract, so the company relented. And McDonald supervised the redesign of the booster rocket joints that had failed. Mark Maier of Chapman University.

MAIER: What we should remember about Al McDonald - he would often stress his laws of the seven Rs. And it was always, always do the right thing...

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

MCDONALD: ...For the right reason at the right time with the right people, and you will have no regrets for the rest of your life. And it's really that simple if you just keep it focused that way.

BERKES: Allan McDonald said he had no regrets. On the 30th anniversary of the Challenger tragedy, he cited another favorite quote. Regret for things we did is tempered by time, he said. But regret for things we did not do is inconsolable. For NPR News, I'm Howard Berkes.

(SOUNDBITE OF OLAFUR ARNALDS'S "PARTIAL") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.